The Recapist

Famesters

LOGIN
REGISTER

Gossip Girl: Seventeen Candles (Episode 108)

If Blair Waldorf's seventeenth birthday party is an espresso, my night was more like a lukewarm mug of chamomile tea. Our entire family got flu shots yesterday, and despite Advil all around, we're hurtin' pups, so bear with me as I try to sort out the sortie for y'all while I type mostly one-handed and go "ow ow ow" a lot.

"Happy Birthday to who? Forget cake and ice cream; I'm saving room for just desserts."

"ONCE I COMMIT TO SOMETHING, I STICK WITH IT" -- Jenny succeeded in convincing AWOLison to come home from Hudson. Rufus remains nonplussed about that for much of the episode. Dan rags on her for leaving in the first place, and Jenny just wants her mama. There's a weird disconnect going on, and I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that the actress cast as AWOLison looks like she should be doing Clearasil ads. Seriously, she could be Jenny's younger sister. Of all the wonderful actresses in New York City who could realistically play the mother of kids who are sixteen and fourteen, they chose her? WTF? She tells Rufus, "My whole adult life has been about you." She means, of course, not just Rufus, but the kids, too. Oh, I'm sorry, AWOLison, that nobody told you parenting isn't the kind of thing you get to quit once your kids hit puberty. In fact, given the evidence we've seen so far, there's never a more important time to be there for your kids. The best advice I ever got as a parent was from Vicki Iovine's Girlfriend's Guide To Toddlers:  "Be present, be loving, be as consistent as possible." I think you'll agree that anything intended for toddlers probably translates well for the teenage years, another stage when hormones take over, tempers flare and it's all about asserting independence. I'm the first to admit that that following Vicki's advice is easier said than done, but the whole "be present" part is a great place to start. AWOLison says to poor pussy-whipped Rufus, "Don't act like you care what I want," and Rufus folds like he's holding a pair of deuces, resulting in make-up sex on the floor. Jenny's all aglow when she finds them in their post-coital haze, chirping, "As you were!" at them, but I don't have a good feeling about this. At all. I think our favorite Humphreys are about to get their collective hearts broken again.

"I TELL VANESSA EVERYTHING. I HAVE SINCE I WAS SIX" -- Blah, blah, blahty blah blah. That's what I hear whenever Vanessa opens her mouth. She seems to have mistaken 'best friend' for 'annoying bitch' as she continues to do her level best to come between Serena and Dan. This leads to Dan bringing Vanessa to Blair's seventeenth birthday bash, where he's meeting Serena as his date. Serena's more magnanimous than I would be in the face of that kind of chutzpah, and graciously goes out of her way to bond with V. There's a Guitar Hero death-match which left both My Mister and me with raised eyebrows. Blake Lively can carry off a hell of a lot with style and pizzazz, but the whole "Freebird" scene went on waaaaaaaaaay too long. In the end, all three are friends? I guess? I might have dozed off somewhere around the time when the term "best friend" got bandied around for the eightieth time.

"I SUCCUMBED TO INEBRIATION, PERFORMED AT A SPEAK-EASY, AND SURRENDERED MY VIRTUE TO A SELF-ABSORBED ASS" -- Just in case there was any lingering doubt that Blair gave it up to Chuck in the back of his limo, she lays it right out there when she goes to "confess" her sins to a priest. He offers her the following sage advice: Don't drink. Keep your clothes on. Try to avoid those who encourage you to stray. Couldn't have said it better myself, Father! Though I might have added, while I had her attention: Treat others the way you want to be treated. What Blair really wants, though, is for the priest to grant her birthday wish. The priest indulgently explains that he's a priest, not a genie, so she says the next time he talks to "Him", to please ask Him to send her boyfriend back, like Nate's a puppy who got out in the yard by accident and has been piddling on the rose bushes and digging up the geraniums.

Our main storylines weave a particularly complex web tonight, with Blair's birthday party at the center. Chuck wants more of that sweet uptown ass, so he's moved into stalking mode. Blair just wants to forget it ever happened, especially since she's determined to get Nate back. She's put jewelry she wants for her birthday on hold at a store, in hopes that her mother and Nate will go buy her something pretty. Even though she and Nate have broken up, she still expects him to come to heel, buy her a present, and call her at midnight, like he's always done. Nate, though, still has a lot more on his mind than Blair, namely his parents' blind refusal to see the shitload of shit they're up to their necks in. His mom, who I think might win the honor for Worst Upper East Side Parent EVER (and when you think of the competition for particular award, it's a little chilling to think of being at the top of that god-awful heap), is still trying to foist blame for Howie's actions on Nate, and still expects him to clean up the family mess. How's he supposed to do that? By getting back together with Blair -- complete with presenting her with the Vanderbilt engagement ring as a "special" birthday gift -- thus re-sealing the fraying edges of the business deal between Bitchy Waldorf and Howie. Nate takes a walk and reluctantly calls Blair, suggesting that maybe they were too hasty with the whole breaking up thing. Blair's delighted that the priest granted her wish so quickly, but rather than be honest and upfront, she plays Nate, telling him they'll have to take it slow and he'll have to really work for it. Because Nate's given us so much reason to believe that hard work is something he enjoys. *eyeroll* He tells Blair he's got a special present he wants to give her, and Blair tells him to bring it to her party, then hangs up before he can say anything else.

From there, Nate goes to see Chuck at The Palace. Chuck's understandably reluctant to let him in. "I can hear you breathing on the other side of the door," Nate says. Hee! Nate spills his guts to a noticeably uncomfortable Chuck, telling him how his parents want him to get back together with Blair to save the business deal. Chuck ponders for a minute, then says, "If you're done with Blair, be done. Don't cave to your parents' wishes if they're not your desires." When Nate calls Chuck on his change of 'tude, reminding him about how he encouraged Nate to seal the deal and tap that ass, Chuck says, "I care about three things, Nathaniel -- money, the pleasures money brings me, and you. I'm just trying to have your back here." My Mister piped up, "Trying to have your backside." And that's why we love My Mister. I can make a whole argument about how Chuck and Blair is really more about Chuck and Nate, but ow ow ow, my arm's killing me, so we're moving on.

At Blair's party, Chuck and Blair have a pretty hysterical exchange that starts off with Blair saying, "You nauseate me." Chuck counters with, "I haven't slept. I feel sick, like there's something in my stomach…fluttering." *snort* Blair tells him to murder those butterflies in his stomach, dismissing him. As GG puts it, Hell hath no fury like Chuck Ass scorned: he takes it upon himself to tell Blair that Nate only wants to get back with her to save the deal between Howie and Eleanor. She's sure he's wrong, and says she knows Nate will call her at midnight, just like he always does. Chuck says if Nate calls, he'll leave Blair alone, but if Chuck "wins," then Blair has to spend the night with him. Okay, y'all. I know there are a lot of Chuck/Blair fans out there, but really? That's just...gross. Chuck's still got to dig himself out of quite a deep hole with me, and betraying his best friend's trust to get in Blair's expensive lingerie isn't the way to do it.

Nate spends most of the evening fretting and wandering, kind of like always, but a chance meeting with Jenny Humphrey outside Blair's party seems to lead him in a new, less passive, less hazy direction, and I'm all for that. He's got the ring in his pocket, but doesn't want to go in; she's avoiding the drama going on at home and would like to go to the party, but feels pretty sure that Blair won't want to see her. Instead, they go for a walk-n-talk, and even though I have to cover my eyes since Taylor Momsen is fourteen and Chace Crawford is twenty-two, they're very sweet together. He tells her about how hard his parents are pushing him to do something he doesn't want to do, and asks, "If I do it now, when does it stop?" She says, wise beyond her years, "It stops when you stop it." As Nate calls a cab to take Jenny home at the end of the evening, he asks if her parents will be mad because she's out so late. She says they won't, because they think she's with a friend. "Then they think right," Nate says, and he's so ridiculously charming that it's no surprise when Jenny gives him a blinding grin and launches herself into his arms, wrapping him up in a big hug. Can't blame her a bit; I'd have done the same in her place!

One of GG's technomice snaps a photo of Nate and his "mystery girl" and sends it to Blair at her party, with a syrupy, "Happy Birthday, B!" text message attached. It's a call at midnight, all right, but not the one Blair had hoped for. Everyone at the party gets a copy of the picture, leading Blair to reveal tearily that yes, she and Nate broke up, and that the only reason he'd get back together would be because of their parents' business deal. Then she exits dramatically, shutting herself off in a conveniently placed bedroom nearby. Chuck comes to talk to her and gives her a beautiful diamond necklace -- the one she'd picked out at the jewelry store and assumed Nate had bought for her. He puts it around her neck and says, "I really am sorry," when Blair says, "I think it's really over." And then he nudges at her and kisses her shoulder and next thing we know, they're at it again! *facepalm* Only this time, Serena sees them; as she pushes open the door slowly, they're writhing around on the bed.

"Spotted: B, turning another year older, but not necessarily wiser."

No shit. Let me get this straight: Blair, who did her best to annihilate her best friend for sleeping with her boyfriend…turns around and sleeps with her boyfriend's best friend. Again. And don't tell me "they were on a break!" because Blair spent the entire episode trying to get Nate back, and then, the minute he didn't call, what, thar she blows!?!?

Remember the three things Chuck says he cares about? Seems to me Blair must go in the category of one of the pleasures money brings him, since she's not Nate, and she's not made of money. It's sad. I'd like to think Chuck is redeemable -- most people are -- but given how easily he was willing to 1) sell out Nate when it gave Chuck an advantage, and 2) hurt Blair to get her back in bed with him, I'm not feeling the Chuck love.

To end on a good note, I'll tell you that Nate goes back home, chucks the ring on the coffee table and tells his parents to go fuck themselves. Oh, he's more polite than that; he was raised right, after all, but he shows both balls and backbone as he stands up to his folks. I have to say, he's incredibly attractive while doing so. Yum. And yay! The first step in solving a problem is admitting your parents have one!

Everything I Need To Know I Learned From Gossip Girl:

Money marries bigger money.
When you get a boyfriend, your best friend gets shafted becomes your second best friend.
Sex is a commodity, like pork bellies and blood diamonds.
The best position to show off a fancy new necklace is flat on your back.








Famester Dish

Read what Famesters are saying:

Anonymous's picture

Blair

Blair didn't do anything wrong. She and Nate weren't definitely back together, and Nate blew her off without a word (he could've texted her earlier or called back to say he wasn't going to her party). And while they were definitely a couple, he and slutty Serena had sex. (Does she ever stand still? Damn, she's annoying.) There was no boyfriend/girlfriend relationship anymore about Blair and Chuck from the moment he refused to say he loved her and she told him she didn't need him. After that, both were entitled to their rebounds. Only this time, Blair went for it. And good thing too: Chuck at least "likes" her.

Ran Cansley's picture

Chuck's a bit of a wild card

I do think Chuck likes Blair, but I still don't trust him. I tend to look at these guys (both here and on FNL) and ask myself if I'd want my daughter to date them if she was a teenager, and the answer for Chuck is an emphatic NO.

As for Blair, I don't really understand her motivations beyond the fact that she's hurt and seems to be acting out in response to that hurt.

Serena's picture

Nice try, Blair, but your

Nice try, Blair, but your logic is tragically flawed. Sure, she and Nate were technically not together, which means she's entitled to rebound to her heart's content, but with her boyfriend's best friend? Really? If you haven't realized that there were ulterior motives involved, then you and I were not watching the same show with the same level of discernment.

You can't honestly tell me that even if you were the one to break up with your boyfriend of 12 years and he turns around and sleeps with your best friend, you would be completely fine with it. After all, you were the one that dumped his ass, so why should you care who he gets busy with? Way to oversimplify a complicated situation.

Are you also forgetting that Chuck has just admitted to having legitimate feelings for Blair despite the fact that she's clearly not over Nate, and you want me to believe Blair is finally succumbing to Chuck's charms because of a pretty shiny necklace? Give me a break. I mean, this is Blair we're talking about here. The little she-devil who was so intent on Serena's "social destruction" a mere five episodes ago. She's demonstrated that she does not deal with slights well and vengeance is her favorite game to play. So not only is she using someone she considers her friend who she knows likes her, she's also bedding him because the same guy happens to be her ex's best friend! You got to give the girl credit: she's killing two bird with one stone all while sticking it to Nate where it would hurt the most. What's even more astonishing (as evident by the next episode's preview) is the return of Bitchy Blair who manages to dredge up Serena's past transgression to use against her because she doesn't want to come to terms with her own reprehensible actions. Klassy!

So, yeah, "Blair didn't do anything wrong." I'd hate to live in your black and white moral vacuum of a world.

Ran Cansley's picture

Wow, Serena, I hope I stay on your good side!

You bring up some interesting points. In a show populated with self-centered people, Blair and Chuck both seem on the extreme end of the "me me me, it's all about me" scale. When they come together, it's half fireworks, half toxic blend.

I don't like what Blair did, but I think Chuck is worse, for using something Nate told him in confidence against both Nate and Blair.

Anonymous's picture

Yesss!!

Thank you Ran, you are a breath of fresh air and sanity in the GG fandom, populated by squealing Blair/Chuck fans.

Ran Cansley's picture

Aww, thanks!

I get the appeal of the bad boy. I do. I get the appeal of a rich guy who gives diamond necklaces, too. I guess I'm too old to be charmed by bad behavior and flash. ;)

Anonymous's picture

Chuck is hot

I'd do him. I think "Serena" was responding to my post about Blair. I'm not Blair. I'm a fan with a black and white moral vacuum to fill with Gossip Girls episodes (more Blair and Chuck scenes, please!).

Just thought I should clarify. :)

Ran Cansley's picture

Hee

Is that vacuum a Hoover or a Dyson? ;)

Personally, I'd like to fill my vacuum with Nate and Serena, preferably naked and entwined, but to each her own. ;)

Caitlin's picture

Re: Blair and Chuck

Blair, who did her best to annihilate her best friend for sleeping with her boyfriend…turns around and sleeps with her boyfriend's best friend. Again. And don't tell me "they were on a break!" because Blair spent the entire episode trying to get Nate back, and then, the minute he didn't call, what, thar she blows!?!?

Well, Nate didn't just not call. He blew off Blair's party, and she can't even pretend it had anything to do with his dad's troubles because everyone and their brother has pictorial evidence that he spent the evening with another girl. After the embarrassing snafu with the ring and the revelation that Nate only considered getting back together with her for his father's sake, I don't think Blair owes Nate anything at all. And if the guy she's picked for her rebound hurts Nate, more's the pity.

Chuck, on the other hand, is definitely doing Nate wrong. At the same time, it's really interesting to watch Chuck manipulate the situation to his advantage, because the advice he gave to Nate was actually GOOD advice! And he did sell out Nate by telling Blair that Nate didn't really want to get back together with her, but I've always got the sense that Blair is Chuck's friend too, and it's something she needed to hear because she obviously wasn't going to face such an unpleasant truth on her own -- not where Nate is involved. So I'm positive that Chuck was rationalizing that he was being a good friend to both Nate *and* Blair while not incidentally getting what he wanted. I mean, it's not pretty, but I really enjoy this aspect of Chuck's characterization. I don't really see a lot of "bad boy appeal" in Chuck, because he's kind of a foppish idiot. But I do find him sort of endlessly entertaining. (Aside from when he's raping people, I mean. *facepalm* What can I say?)

Anyway, if Blair and Chuck had done as they should, it would have been a boring episode. No show can survive without antagonists, and I find Blair to be an incredibly sympathetic and interesting one.

And in response to the above conversation, I'd say that Blair isn't sleeping with Chuck merely for revenge or because he gave her a shiny present. Chuck is actually PAYING ATTENTION to Blair, which must be kind of a revelation after Nate being so hilariously disinterested for the past year. Blair is hurt, confused, angry and responding to Chuck's advances in a very human way, IMHO.

As for the previews for next week, I am not surprised that Blair gets defensive about sleeping with Chuck. She knows that she's not being classy, and in her mind, who the hell is Serena to judge her? (And if Blair hadn't brought up Nate/Serena, I would have scoffed at the lack of continuity.) Plus I think it's a lot easier for Blair to say out loud that she's messing around with Chuck for revenge than to admit that she has no idea what she's doing.

Just my 2 cents. Or, um, twenty dollars. Sorry, this was kind of long. Enjoyed the recap, as usual!

Ran Cansley's picture

I love the passion the show inspires! Talk all you want! :)

You raise really interesting points, Caitlin. Blair is a really complex character, and I think you're right that she doesn't always know why she's doing what she's doing. She's a classic teenager in that regard, underneath her surface sophistication.

Reading your comment reminded me of how much I came to sympathize with Blair as she's written in the books, and I hope the same will happen with the TV Blair. I don't think the show is as kind to her as the books were. Chuck plays a MUCH bigger role in the TV show than the books. Their dynamic is almost purely an invention of the show, so I don't have the additional foundation of the characters as I got to know them from the books to support how I see them now.

I'm reading the prequel now, and I'm STUPIDLY in love with Nate, Serena AND Blair; I want that to translate to the show!

Wow, talk about long-winded. *poke* You still awake? ;)