The Recapist

Famesters

LOGIN
REGISTER

Life On Mars: Out Here in the Fields (Episode 101)

"You're some bottom-feeding thug that crawled out of some dark pit in the recesses of my mind."

Let's get a couple things clear, yeah?

I adore the original Life on Mars. I think John Simm is awesome He rocks Spy's world.

Now that that's out here, I will try to be as unbiased as possible about Life on Mars US. I'm going to try not to compare every single scene to the original episode.

The key world there is 'try.' I'm not promising anything.

I'm in England (no really, I'm on vacation) where I'm recovering from a night spent on the floor of a public toilet throwing up because I shouldn't have gone drinking with the English.

But what a better time to do this recap.

We start with the obligatory establishing shots that lets us know we're in New York First smart thing they did from the original premiere. LA? Seriously? First thing about LOM - no sun, ever. We need lots for grey for the leather jacket.

Sam and Cosby Kid Maya are on the way to a scene (note the sirens) so it's a great time to have a relationship discussion.

This is called establishing the relationship like New York, but with less skyscrapers. Turns out Maya is holding something against Sam while said while either drunk or horny. Sam doesn't really protest that much about meeting her parents and instead says he's crazy about her. Crazy being the general theme of the show.

Right, so now we're watching the take down of Colin Raimes I'm really not going to describe this as it's your standard chase the bad guy down, blah, blah, dustbin cover to the face, blah, blah, handcuffs. and the interrogation.

Now, if you've seen the original, you know what happens next. If you don't, Raimess' attorney pulls out a tape that shows that Raimes couldn't have been the serial killer because while the victim was being killed, he was off gambling in a casino which ended up with him being filmed on CCTV.

Maya stalks the freed Raimes through a park and she and Sam have another relationship chat. Then, in a soap-opera-worthy moment we learn that Raimes has a twin brother named Laurence Raimes, a degenerate gambler (who was on the CCTV).

Oooh! Drama!

As expected, when Sam rushes to the park, he only finds Maya's blood-stained white shirt.

Cue montage of Sam driving with angst and some Bowie.

Yes, that song.

And he gets hit by a car.

More Bowie.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ <---- time travel squiggles

Well, at least the leather jacket is black. (Beige, my ass.)

Sam wakes up confused and sees an orange car with black racing stripes. He peers in it only to see an eight track with another Bowie song, maybe not so aptly named 'Hunky Dory.'

While Sam is being confused, a beat cop comes by to bark at him about parking. Sam denies ownership of the car and comments about jeeps and cells. Yes, this is tedious but it's being used to set the fact that Sam does have a presence and legal identity wherever he is. Yes, we all know he's in 1973, but let's pretend we don't know yet. It'll make Sam feel better.

Well, until he turns around and sees the twin towers of the World Trade Center. I'm Canadian and while I understand intellectually the horror of that day, I don't have the emotional tie to the Towers as the intended audience.

But now Sam knows it's time for the 'What the fuck?!?!?! moment.

Title sequence. The BBC's was better.

Random comment. At least the pants are red, or is that brown? Sam walks around a lot more getting more and more confused. He finds his cop ID and goes to the station. There he (and we) get to experience of some serious old-school police equipment. You know the CSIS on Vegas, Miami and New York would just cry if they saw this shit.

US Chris comes by followed by US Ray really for no other reason that to walk them across the screen so we can see they're there, and to further establish Sam's credentials - yeah, he's from Hyde (which is upstate now). For the record, there are places called Hyde in:

Pennsylvania
North Carolina
South Dakota

Sam gets all ranty, demanding an answer for this bullshit only to be slapped down by the man who is old enough to qualify for the AARP. I mean, we're supposed to believe this guy is in the prime of his booze-soaked life?

Uh, the fan is a bit much, even for Keitel/The Boss/Gene Hunt, but don't worry, Gene shows us he's a man's man when Sam gets a punch in the gut. (That's a sign of love, really)

Sam tries to reach Maya, but the operater thinks he's nuts and soon so does he when he hears the sound of medical equipment.

Much screaming ensues. Ray, being his charming self deems Sam crazy and decides he needs to see No Nuts.

Enter Annie Norris. Huh, I think I have that same skirt, pockets and all. No Nuts Norris gives us her story - she's basically the housewife of the police force.

Sam gets an intro to the era's blatant sexism when Gene and the boys take him along to a crime scene (Dead twirl, no sexual assault, etc.) The description is exactly like the current case Sam's working on, so he wonders if that's why he's in 1973. Gene makes it all about him, and tells Chris and Ray to take Sam to the slab.

Sam tries to use his forensic mojo, but the other guys are all, "What? Dude, what are you on?"

Btw, smoking over the body is just so respectful, isn't it?

Turns out the victim was held for 30 hours without food and really, who cares because Sam is stressing out again. Ray tries to be helpful in only a way Ray can be - it includes booze and an airplane hostess.

Sam instead goes for the tweezers and grabs a hair.

Scene change. Yeah, I would jump too if I was having a great dream involving my partner only to have Harvey Keitel walk in. If this was the original LOM, this would have been the jumping off point for some jealous!Gene slash fic

Sam is still insisting that the serial killer took a 35-year break, but even he doesn't need to see the looks on his team's face to realize that yes, his theory is a bit stupid.

Annie No Nuts gets the job of taking him home to his new flop and we get another montage of life in 1973 New York

(This is like the aerial shots of Torchwood in Season one. I'll wait a couple more episodes before berating the directors.)

Random note: Damn, those clothes were ugly. Just like his apartment. It's a dive - the bathroom is down the hall. Annie even unpacked his clothes. She really is the housewife of the department.

Sam gives us his three theories - he's a time traveller, he's crazy or he's in a coma in a hospital.

Ok, side note. I still miss John Simm.

Moving on. Sam unburdens to Annie, who doesn't take him seriously, but uses her psych degree to rationalize his feelings and circumstances.

Annie makes a crack about letting his hand linger on her chest, but by the angst on his face, Sam's not thinking about her breasts.

Oh, science guy on TV. Science guy tells us that Sam is in a low responsive, but not persistently vegetative state. Sam shouts and paws at the tv.

We switch to the interrogation scene and a view of the totally illegal awesome techniques used by Gene.

Well, at least Dora and I agree. Gene is ugly. Not well-aged like Glenister, who was good looking when he was younger. Keitel just looks like he's going to keel over and break his hip. He could hold it together with that tie.

Sam gets kicked out and goes to the bar. Nelson is from Poughkeepsie.

Gene comes in to rub in his awesome techniques. Sam tries to use logic and modern-day forensics. Gene just laughs.

Gene gives him his work philosophy and even gives Sam a chance to use his skills to find the killer. This includes a quick history in profiling, which is only there for more sexist comments against Annie. Oh, and the emotional connection between Sam and Annie. They have a moment over the imagined death of a girl and then Annie tells him to never do that again. Sam brings out his inner feminist by saying, "What? Ask you to use your brain for five minutes."

Random note, not Bowie, but why use Teenage Wasteland, the same song used for CSI NY?

Annie explains for us what it's like as a woman of the time. I quite like the explanation. Theory is ok, but living it is something else.

Another montage with a Wizard of Oz reference.

LOL! Aw, Sam wants to impress Annie by the quick change from Hall and Oates to Zepplin album. Sam possibly ruins the future by telling her about CDs. The record store conveniently gives Sam the next clue - insulation.

Chris comes up with something to move the plot along. Mrs. Raimes, the grandmother of Colin Raimes, made a complaint about a neighbour. Granny dear is trying to distract them by raving about the coffee and the cookies. Sam's method isn't working, so Gene buys her expensive cookies and feeds her booze. Hell, even before she drinks the booze-laced coffee she's spilling the beans on her downstairs neighbour Willie Kramer. He plays his phonograph (record player) all night long.

Sam and Gene share a significant look. Then, wait for it - the leap over the desk! Not as dramatic as the original, but I'll take it.

Gene and Sam head over to Willie's place, see the room covered in insulation and rescues Dora. Willie comes home, sees the cops and a hilarious chase scene ensues to the song "Little Willy" by Sweet.

Willie holds a gun on Sam while Sam tries to talk him down. Sam thinks Willie might be the key to sending him back to 2008 and encourages Willie to shoot him.

Then Gene and Ray kicks Willie's ass.

This time Sam's crazy is deemed good. Sam sees Willie being waved at by two redheaded children - Colin and Laurence Raimes. Sam puts the pieces together and with a brief conversation with Annie, he walks away into a another montage, this time set to the Rolling Stones. He does drive by to watch Colin Raimes play with kids. He warns Colin, who is a child, so I'm not sure if Sam's action will help Maya in the future.

Then it's not so much taking to Colin as it's taking to himself. Then Maya's voice comes over the radio, encouraging Sam to come home. Sam angsts, but is distracted by Chris calling him on a new case.

Sam drives away with sirens blazing and Mick Jagger wailing.

The recapper is feeling: a sense of deja vu.








Famester Dish

Read what Famesters are saying:

carlz31's picture

*sigh* I was going to try so

*sigh* I was going to try so hard to keep an open mind about this show cause I loved the BBC version so very much. That being said, IMO this version can't hold a candle to the original. (Does that have something to do with the fact that I've developed a wee crush on John Simm?)

Anyway, that being said, I thought your recap was great! I especially loved the time travel squiggles. I have no idea why, but they made me giggle a lot. And I love struck out text. And you were totally right about the episode, especially Gene. I miss Glenister too, and I think thats the main problem with redoing such a successful show. The characters have already been established and played really well (by awesome actors), and then you have to recast them in a way that doesn't destroy whats already been done in the original (Yes, I really miss John Simm. Could you tell?)

Anyway, good job! Sorry, I tend to ramble a little when I try to type anything...

Oh, on a side note, I originally thought my reaction to the US version would be something along the lines of "O_O...DOESN'T CANON MEAN ANYTHING TO YOU PEOPLE?! *runs off crying*", and while it was a little, my reaction was more along the lines of "...please don't beat this show to within an inch of it's life...please"

travellingone's picture

No, no - a crush on John

No, no - a crush on John Simm is not only appropriate, it's expected.

I'm glad you liked the time travel squiggles!

I'm not sure how I feel about the show, but I'm sure I'll come to a conclusion very soon. However, one thing that won't change is the fact that I think Keitel is too old for the role.

Thanks for commenting!

carlz31's picture

Hee, it so is :) I admit,

Hee, it so is :)

I admit, I'm trying very hard to let go of the original in regards to the remake, but I'm trying really hard to view the show as it's own entity, and not as opposed to the BBC version. That being said, as its own entity, I thought the show was actually alright. But I'm having a lot of trouble not comparing it to the original. I mean, John Simm and Philip Glenister together is the epitome of awesome in my mind (well, chuck in David Tennant, then it's the epitome of awesome)

But I will continue to watch until I make a definitive decision in my mind. And I'll definately continue reading the recaps :)

travellingone's picture

I think the hardest part is

I think the hardest part is keeping the two shows separate. I think it can be done, but the US show is going to have to really try to break away from the original without losing the flavour that made the original so good.

We'll see.

The Notorious JMG's picture

Some agreement

I thought ABC did a decent job recreating a Beeb masterpiece... although Jason O'Mara and Harvey Keitel will never, EVER be John Simm and Phil Glenister.
Nonetheless, I'll watch again - and I'll DEFINITELY continue reading your recaps (not that I haven't already been reading your DW and TW recaps for, what, a year plus now?).
Oh, and by the way, when I got to your Torchwood-shot snark, I laughed so loud I scared the dog.

travellingone's picture

To be honest, it wasn't as

To be honest, it wasn't as bad as I expected and I was ready to hate it. I'm going to give it a chance.

Btw, you know I'm not Spy, right? I cover for her when she can't do Who or Torchwood, but I'm not her.

Spy's picture

ZOMG! It's finally gotten

ZOMG! It's finally gotten to the point where people can't tell us apart by snark alone!

The Notorious JMG's picture

Oh hell. Yes, I know the

Oh hell. Yes, I know the difference between you two. Yes, I was confused.
No, I was not drunk. I have no excuse.

No, I DO have an excuse. I was so confused at not seeing Simm & Glenister that I got mixed up.

travellingone's picture

Totally valid reason.

Totally valid reason.

Ms Gypsy's picture

It wasn't THAT bad

True, Keitel is too old for the role but he's got the attitude for the role and I don't think they cast him for his boundless good looks. And I miss John Simm sooooooooooooooooo much!

But I enjoyed this. The reaction to the sight of the Twin Towers was played so very well that I sat up and took notice (although up until that point I'd been a trifle bored.) I confess I was waiting for Barney Miller to show up at a few points (or Fish. What I wouldn't have given for a ten second flash of Abe Vigoda at one of the desks!) but in general it felt good. I hope they give up exact duplication of the original because New York is NOT Manchester and there is no way to keep this going if they don't let it go off on its own.

The US has had middling to poor success imitating UK shows. I'd call this one of the rare successes, although I would agree it's not a rousing success.

When Fox TV gets around to remaking "Ab Fab" I'll happily join what I hope will be legions of Americans in ignoring it and tossing manure as needed. But this time I think the US producers did okay.

We need the children of Indonesia and the Philippines to manufacture our freedom of choice.
Marc Maron

travellingone's picture

I did like the use of the

I did like the use of the twin towers as the major indicator of Sam's displacement in time (if that is what happened). It also firmly set the show in New York.

bubbleslayer's picture

I've never seen the BBC

I've never seen the BBC version, and honestly, the trailers for the US version just didn't catch my attention. I plan to read your recaps, and if it looks interresting enough, I'll give it a try....

So basically, it's all on your shoulders....

:::snicker:::

(a huge drawback for me is HK, I cannot stand that man...)

travellingone's picture

You should watch the BBC

You should watch the BBC version, it's really very good. Spy and I have copies on our computers. Next time we see each other, we should watch it.

bubbleslayer's picture

Sounds like a plan! I've

Sounds like a plan!

I've tried to find it myself, but it's not available from any of the usual sources.

Spy's picture

*Crawls out of computer

*Crawls out of computer malfunction hell.*

The time travel squiggles are spectacular. I miss John Simm too (he rocks my world) but I was happy to see how much this Sam improved, and how the Annie is recast. (yay!) I was also terribly excited when I saw the red pants and black jacket. If you weren't in the UK at the time, i would've called you and squeed.

travellingone's picture

It wasn't as horrific as the

It wasn't as horrific as the original premiere ep. We'll see where it goes.

Spy's picture

This one was much better. I

This one was much better. I actually enjoyed it, even though the best part of the pilot (the scene on the roof) was left out.
BTW, shouldn't you be getting to A Thing in Cardiff? According to my schedule, you've got A Thing there, don't you?

turlington.christy's picture

Reply

Please, Tennant, don't leave me
Lateral Designs Inc | Lateral Design Inc | Lateral Designs

turlington.christy's picture

Reply

dai123's picture

replica watches

emselves with larger cheap jewelry sAle emselves with larger cheap bvlgAri on sale